Ranking The Expansions

Before I get started, I recognize that the current expansion isn’t over. There is more content to come, but at this point I think it’s fair to say we can at least gauge Battle For Azeroth against all that came before it. I don’t foresee something earth shattering in what will likely be the final patch of this expansion. So where does BFA rank? Let’s take a look, shall we?

7. Warlords of Draenor
WoW’s fifth expansion had all the potential in the world. We were going back in time in an alternate timeline. It was a great “What If?” opportunity. Unfortunately, it fell somewhat flat. We got a few little “what if” moments, none bigger than in the cinematic. We also had the chance to see what Outland looked like long ago and were able to learn about some of those past stories. But other than that, Warlords really didn’t contribute anything to the game. Yes, Cymre was now in the game, but that couldn’t save it.  There wasn’t enough content over the course of the expansion, we had to wait for Tanaan (and it was also underwhelming), slog through Garrison quests in each zone, and the sweetest moment of all…Garrosh’s death, was taken out of our hands just so Thrall could do it. That scenario sums up the expansion pretty well.

6. Legion
I might get some backlash for ranking this one so low, it just depends on your perspective. Unlike Warlords, though, Legion isn’t that bad so much as the other expansions are just that much better. I quite enjoyed Legion. The class halls were an interesting idea in concept. But they were another Garrison, and the awesome legendary weapons we got only lasted one expansion. It made me wonder: why bother? Illidan’s redemption was the main purpose of this expansion in terms of lore. That and to catch the evil Gul’dan who escaped Warlords. I didn’t mind Illidan’s story and the way the Demon Hunter lore was woven in worked for me. And, it was a decent new class.  No complaints about the instances or raids. Also, unlike WoD, Legion saw two major deaths in Varian and Vol’jin. The latter is still contributing to in-game content as we try to figure out who told him to make Sylvanas warchief.  As for Varian, he was “betrayed” by the banshee queen and died to save the rest. So the two sides were friendly for as long as the cinematic. Ok…

5. Battle for Azeroth
I’m admittedly torn on the current expansion, despite feeling this is its place on the list.  I’ve been happy with the content thus far, though I’ve not gotten a chance to instance much. That’s been the fault of my schedule. Setting aside my thoughts on Sylvanas herself, the overall narratives of BfA have been well executed. Jaina conquering her guilt, Vol’jin hunting about in the spirit worlds, Saurfang’s plight (easily one of the best stories Blizzard has told in a long time) and the in-game options that creates. We got Allied Races, which I think was a good way to introduce new player races without it feeling like the way the other new races had been brought into the game for the players. I also like how nearly all zones were adjusted to the Guild Wars 2 model, where zones leveled up as you did. The first time I rolled through Duskwood I had completely forgotten that nugget. The reason I don’t rank it higher is because it feels like it’s going to be looked back on as a stepping stone to what comes next (which I expect to be announced at BlizzCon).

4. Mists of Pandaria
I suspect many will rank this one higher but hopefully when I get to the next one on the list you’ll know why I listed them the way I did. First off, the Pandaria cinematic is one of the best Blizzard has given us. On top of that, we got a new class in the Monk and more interestingly a new race that could be Horde or Alliance. How sweet was that? We got our content at a reasonable pace, all building to bat crazy Garrosh but also having some things to satiate the players on the way including the Thunder Isle, Island of Giants, Timeless Isle (wow, Pandaria was like Azeroth’s Hawaii with all those islands). The lore of the Sha was well done. I loved that it became our fault. The instances were almost all well done, with the Mogu’shan ones and Stormstout Brewery among my favourites.  I just wish I had the chance to run Siege of Orgrimmar.

3. Cataclysm
That trailer still gives me chills.  Cataclysm was the expansion that impacted WoW the most. Two new races, new class and race combos (some of which were overdue…Troll Druid and Tauren Priest anyone?) new zones, and an overhaul of most other zones cosmetically and in execution. At this point in time we weren’t sick of Thrall being the focal point of a lot of quests and the Mary Sue Mage (Khadgar) wasn’t around yet either. And let’s not forget old world flight! Cataclysm brought a lot to Azeroth, more than most expansions and that’s why it’s ranked higher than the others. It’s not like it wasn’t without it’s faults. They were there. Heck, even the zone overhaul I just mentioned backfired. If you went to an area and decided to have your hand held during the on-rails questing, the end of the chain was grey for you because you had already out-leveled it much earlier in the zone.  Vashj’ir was a brilliant idea for an underwater zone…it did not play out as brilliantly, particularly combat. Not to mention how disjointed leveling through the new zones was. You were literally continent (and ocean) hopping. But, I feel as though the expansion had enough positives that outweighed the numerous shortcomings.

2. Burning Crusade
The one that started it all. BC expanded on WoW for the first time, bringing a new world with it in Outland. We got Blood Elves and Draenei, which also gave the Horde and Alliance access to Paladins and Shaman respectively. Dailies became a thing, and you had plenty of choices from the Netherwing to the Isle of Quel’Danas. I personally hated Hellfire Penninsula because of all the stupid boars, but it was an introduction into how the quest hubs would flow (and they did). Off the top of my head I can’t think of a single instance that bothered me. I didn’t go out to The Eye much, but I’ve spent plenty of time in the rest. We got a fantastic array of raids, from Magtheridon’s Lair to Karazhan and Zul’Aman, and finally Sunwell Plateau. I have fantastic memories of all of it. Zangarmarsh remains one of my favourite zones in the entire game.

1. Wrath of the Lich King
It’s clichéd to many to say it, but this was the pinnacle of World of Warcraft. Not because of how far the game has fallen since, but because it’s a testament to just how good this expansion was. We got our first class since launch in the Death Knight (which was not surprisingly ridiculously OP). We got a new continent on Azeroth itself for the first time, and everything in Northrend fit. The lore that tied it all together was fantastic, and unlike every expansion since, Arthas mocked us at every turn. He showed up constantly to taunt us, in what was the perfect build to what would eventually be our final clash with him. And all the dungeons and raids that lead to him were enjoyable, with Ulduar easily being my favourite despite it’s difficulty. Classes were relatively balanced and that meant for solid PvP. Personally, I loved Wintergrasp, though I know many didn’t. Inscription was a game changer of a profession for a little while with a wide array of glyphs (which in hindsight wasn’t the best addition to combat). Did it have flaws? Of course, nothing is perfect. But from the pre-Wrath event until the addition of Ruby Sanctum, things just clicked and never stopped being enjoyable.

So..agree? Disagree? Do you think I’m right in where Battle for Azeroth sits? And where will the next expansion fit into the echelon?

7 thoughts on “Ranking The Expansions

  1. tomeoftheancient July 17, 2019 / 2:09 pm

    My ranking is partially based on emotions rather than the quality of the expansion. I’ve got two number 1s.

    1. Wrath of the Lich King
    This is my emotional number one, I loved this expansion. It all came together for me perfectly. I remember it was around Christmas and every time I’d read about the coming cataclysm I would just about tear up. I did NOT want to leave Wrath.

    1. Mists of Pandaria
    The art and music of WoW has always been wonderful to me but in this expansion they knocked it out of the park for me. I love to go back to visit to just hang around, visit NPCs. So, so beautiful.

    2. Burning Crusade
    Lol, I had a love/hate relationship with Hellfire Penninsula. I liked to get scared by the reaver. Nagrand is another zone that I’ll visit the expac just to stop by and enjoy the scenery.

    3. Warlords of Draenor
    Yeah, I didn’t have a problem with this one although I know many did. I didn’t mind the Garrison and loved most of the zones.

    4. Cataclysm
    This is another emotional one. There was nothing wrong with it. I had and still have a problem with them CHANGING THE WORLD. Where is my beautiful Darkshore. I just didn’t deal with the changes well and still don’t. If I make a Night Elf since then I level in the SW Human area because the changes at their home make me too sad. Yes, I’m a complete wingnut.

    5. Battle for Azeroth
    I’m fine with BfA, I might be being hard on it because I’m trying to get flying right now and it’s taking me forever.

    6. Legion
    BOOOOO hisssssssss on Legion. That’s a shame because Suramar and the story was wonderful, I loved Stormheim, as always it was beautiful but who the hell thought freaking destroying professions would be a fun idea.

    Oddly I didn’t even know how important they were to me. I didn’t make money of them but I enjoyed having all my alts proficient in their choosen profession. Cat went through the agony of visiting all the raids or dungeons to level hers up but she’s the only character that did.

    I mean at least if you want to poke professions have it be relevant to the profession. If it’s leatherworking then make like a world boss dragon you have to defeat to get his skin, or something jeeeezzzz. Really, really bummed about that. Whoever came up with that bright idea should be demoted. So there. Jerk.

    So as a result I pretty much stopped playing alts which I had loved to do. I’m trying to get them going again but WTF whoever you are, probably Hazzikostas. I even canceled my subscription but because it’s a six month one never quit because it freaked my husband out lol. I don’t know I think he thought if I cancelled WoW my next move would be jump off the roof!

    Oops, got all worked up, I’ll shut up now!

    • JD Kenada July 19, 2019 / 8:18 am

      Yeah, I’m not a fan of the change to professions at all.

      You make a great point about the aesthetics of Pandaria. Artistically it probably is number one.

  2. Christopher Morgan Frazier July 28, 2019 / 3:34 pm

    1. Wrath of the Lich King
    (I won’t even let people come on my house who disagree here.)
    2. Mists of Pandaria
    (Most underrated expansion ever. But some people couldn’t get past Ohmergerd Pandas but Monks Rock)
    3. Burning Crusade
    (Obviously it was a great expansion but some of the zones like Blades edge holds it back)
    4. Cataclysm
    (Dragon Soul was a good raid. The others were not. But overall at the time adding Arch, new zones and two races mattered.)
    5. Warlords of Draenor
    (Yes this lacked content. Yes the content scrapped would have made it great. Yes Garrisons sucked. But the classes in WoD were in the last best state they have ever been in. Also BRF and HFC were amazing.)
    6. Legion
    (Yeah the raids were alright. But Argus was a nightmare. Legiondaries were a horrible idea. The grind was very real just to be raid viable to get them and RNG on top of RNG on top of RNG is no fun. Artifacts were a horrible grind and class halls were garrisons. Demon Hunters were the only thing I loved.)
    7. BFA
    (During Legion I promised my friends BFA couldn’t be worse and the heart grind was dumb. Azerite gear is even worse. It started off in a bad state and classes were more pruned than ever. Nazjatar and Mechagon are a needed step in the right direction and I could see BFA end up surpassing Legion and WOD if the next patches are good)

  3. wormy July 28, 2019 / 3:59 pm

    There was enough lore up to Lich King /WarCraft 1, 2 and 3)
    Everything after it was severly lacking. MoP was a new lore and good to follow.

    Will be interesting how Classic will fare

  4. Flinchy July 29, 2019 / 12:15 pm

    Agree with everything except move WoD to #3 and shift all the rest down. WoD had flaws, garrisons being a major one, but world, quest, dungeon, raid design was all 100% on point.

    Oh wait no don’t move the rest down. Just swap WoD and Cata. Cata was trash start to finish and I can’t think of a single positive feature.


  5. Alvaro Castillo July 29, 2019 / 2:09 pm

    My Ranking having played since day 1 (about 4th day, considering all the lag, and it was impossible to get in the servers)

    1. Wrath of the Lich King
    Loved the story, the pacing, the friends, everything was kinda new or old with a twist. I was also raiding in a top 30 guild so the memories are great. Those nights getting the Light of Dawn and Death’s Demise titles are one of the best memories ever! And I mean, the end boss was the MOTHA F*****N LICH KING! That’s just unbeatable to us WC3 players.

    2. Legion
    To me, it was a fantastic experience. Artifacts (one of the best mechanics ever along with the halls), world quests, lore all over the place, great raids, Suramar, the mage tower was fantastic. Great, great expansion to me, reignited my love for WoW after WoD. The endgame bosses are unbeatable, I mean titans!

    3. Mists of Pandaria
    I didn’t raid this expansion in a serious guild, only LFR or Normal Pugs, but loved the thematic (I hated it when they announced it, but gave the chance to the exp). The farm, the zones, the lore, not that fond of the pandas, but oh well. Great overall expansion. Loved the Sha!

    4. Burning Crusade
    Good expansion, loved the story, a lot of stuff was pretty new, kinda grindy tbh, but it was really fun to run all over the place, seeing weird stuff, flying rocks, the raids were average in my opinion, with the exception of Sunwell. Last expansion where you needed resistance gear (loved the concept) for the whole raid (Sindragosa doesn’t count, you could kill it with only the tanks in resistance gear). Introduced dailies. Illidan was a lackluster expansion boss.

    5. Battle for Azeroth
    Another good expansion in my opinion. The best part for me is the story and lore, but I’m horde and it is sometimes tiring to much troll-stuff all over the place, like Boralus better. Love the lovecraftian themes. It is 5th only because the other 4 were better, still an enjoyable expansion. The Allied Races are a great addition.

    5.5 Vanilla
    Not an expansion, but I would put Vanilla here. The world was great, it was actually difficult to level (all that continent hopping to get to 60), everything was new, gear was actually an upgrade, but it was REALLY grindy, clunky mechanics, 10 to 15 players were the only ones that carried the raid with all those afking hunters. The game was new and it was great, but compared to all the new stuff, to me is down here.

    6. Cataclysm
    Average expansion. The raids were the best part, but the areas in general were lackluster, Deathwing to the world wasn’t as menacing as I would liked it to be, the world was a mess after that, all those timelines intertwined.

    7. Warlords of Draenor
    The biggest disappointment of all the expansions. Loved the theme, seeing Draenor in all its glory, but there was no content, no Faralon, the Jungle was BORING AF, only the second raid was good, a lot of missed opportunities (no Shattrat, no Temple/Spire Faction Hubs)… The only expansion where I cancelled my sub for a while.

  6. DeafZephyr July 29, 2019 / 10:16 pm

    I agree, aside from one mess up.
    1. WoTLK
    2. BC
    3. Cata
    4. BFA
    5. MoP
    6. Legion
    7. WoD

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s